Good to hear

That's where we don't agree (it's not like we have to lol).
I don't consider what we're talking about a benefit at all. It's the opposite, it's a penalty.
What you consider winning (the 3rd game), I consider the natural course of things (3 games per week, which should be the normal case, during the regular season).
I consider
not having the 3rd game a penalty, since I'm being taken that away, not by choice, talent or challenge but a schedule glitch (allow me to have that, i think it has nothing to do with the ASG, at all).
I would say that what you're saying is already happening in the previous rounds. You have to manage your team/squad well and make options, in order to try winning league games and/or going further in the cup. But that's the thing... that's already the usual for the other rounds, so why would that be so special here? Remember, you're not getting an extra, it's the others that are being penalized (you may not see it that way but it is, it's the others that lose a game, you're not gaining one... you still have the same old 3 games, the others (the vast majority) are "doomed" to 2 (and it's implications)). That's part of what bugs me... this little "thing" throws a wrench into the work you've been doing from the beginning.
Don't get me wrong, I can't speak the same way because being a lower division player, I'm sure I haven't been able to be through the same challenges you have but yes, I believe it's compelling. The cup choice
shouldn't be about getting an extra game at all, it's already the reward of winning those games ($$) and the competition itself. You play to win the cup (and $), not to get playing time (or I would think).
I agree with you that I may not have the best perspective about those "wider reaching effects" you mention, since I don't have a clear view of the schedule problems and so on. I wouldn't change the schedule at all, just have everyone have 3 games that week (via friendly, generated game or whatever) lol
Anyway, different points of view, I guess.
But if you can/wish to elaborate the problems about those "wider reaching effects", I would gladly hear (and hopefully learn) about them.