If this is for D.3 I wouldn't take either one, I would get one with better ID. I would rather have someone like 13/13/13/7 for inside skills with good stamina and FT and decent secondaries.
ID is far more important than IS.
When you consider the importance of both skills, IS is one part of several skills needed to get a successful basket. ID is primarily what creates unsuccessful shots. 10 IS a lot less beneficial than 10 ID.
Same goes for OD.
As a result, I wouldn't be looking at either of those Cs on my team.