For example, what would you guys take 4th in the draft, a 5 star skills rest unknown, a 3 star C skills and 3 star potential 19 year old or 4 star B skills, 19 year old with 2 star potential? These are the sort of guys that will be 4-11 on my draft board.
Neither of the 19-year-old prospects seem very intriguing. I'd put all of your 5-star once-scouted prospects above them. It's always best to go for the home run in the draft over the average prospect. I had a similar situation last year. I had a pretty good season, so I ended up with the 13th pick. The 5-star once-scouted player I received had superstar potential, and I was able to sell him for more than $2,000,000. With that, I was able to turn around and buy an established center with salary around $50K.